Latest
Friday, October 9, 2026
  • New YorkNY
  • LondonLDN
  • TokyoTYO
Sports

Cleveland Guardians Comeback in Game 4 Forces Deciding Fifth Game

The Cleveland Guardians staged an incredible comeback in Game 4 of the ALDS on Thursday night, forcing a deciding fifth game back in Cleveland on Saturday night.

Guardians erupt in sixth inning to stun White Sox in Game 4 of ALDS, force deciding Game 5
Source: CBS Sports

The Cleveland Guardians staged an incredible comeback in Game 4 of the ALDS on Thursday night, outscoring the Chicago White Sox 9-5 and forcing a deciding fifth game back in Cleveland on Saturday night.

In a thrilling turn of events, the Guardians erased a one-run deficit to take control of the game, scoring six crucial runs in the sixth inning. This dramatic shift in momentum proved too much for the White Sox to overcome, as they were unable to recover from their deficit and secure a series-clinching win at home.

The White Sox had appeared poised to wrap up the series with a convincing performance, building a 2-0 lead early on and expanding it to 4-3 after five innings. However, the Guardians refused to back down, pushing through a crucial moment in the game when they needed it most.

Patrick Bailey sparked the Guardians' resurgence with a solo home run in the top of the fifth inning, cutting the White Sox's lead to 2-1 and giving his team new life. The momentum then shifted decisively in favor of the Guardians, thanks to José Ramírez's powerful two-run homer off White Sox reliever Jordan Hicks.

Ramírez's impressive blast catapulted the Guardians into a 3-2 lead, marking a pivotal turning point in the game as it flipped the momentum firmly in their favor. The White Sox were left reeling from this unexpected setback and struggled to regain their footing thereafter.

The Guardians' remarkable comeback has set up an exciting conclusion to the series, with the winner advancing to face the Tampa Bay Rays in the ALCS. Saturday's deciding Game 5 will be a highly anticipated showdown between these two teams, each eager to secure its place in the championship race.

The momentum shifted dramatically in favor of the Guardians as they exploded for five crucial runs in the sixth inning. A leadoff walk and subsequent one-out walk set up Munetaka Murakami for a big hit, which he delivered with a single to left field that loaded the bases.

The White Sox responded by scoring two runs to take a 4-3 lead. However, the Guardians' bullpen was able to stem the tide, as Erik Sabrowski entered the game and struck out Braden Montgomery to end the threat. This pivotal moment in the game seemed like a crucial turning point for the Guardians.

With one out, Angel Martínez was hit by a pitch and then stole second base, setting up Travis Bazzana for a big opportunity. He capitalized on it with a double that scored Martínez and gave the Guardians their first lead of the game.

The Guardians continued to pour it on, as Bailey singled home the go-ahead run, followed by two walks that loaded the bases. Ramírez then stepped up with a single that plated another run, making it 6-4 in favor of the Guardians. Chase DeLauter added another run with a single, leaving the bases still loaded.

The Guardians' offense, which had been quiet for much of the series, finally erupted in the sixth inning to take a commanding 9-4 lead over the White Sox in Game 4 of the ALDS.

The home runs that the Guardians hit were their first two of the postseason, and they came at a crucial time as the team was trying to break out of its slump. The Guardians' offense had been struggling all season long, ranking among the worst in baseball in terms of scoring runs.

In Game 2, Gavin Williams had pitched well for the Guardians, allowing just two runs over five innings with 11 strikeouts. However, he was removed from the game after giving up a single, and the bullpen allowed the runner to score, ultimately costing him a win.

The White Sox attempted to mount a comeback in the ninth inning, but it was too little, too late. Miguel Vargas led off the frame with a home run, but the Guardians were able to escape the inning without allowing any further damage.

The series has been marked by creative pitching decisions, with both teams using relievers and starters interchangeably throughout the games so far. This approach may continue in Game 5, which will determine the winner of the ALDS.

The Guardians' pitching plans for a potential Game 6 are now uncertain due to the extended usage of closer Cade Smith and starter Noah Syndergaard in Game 4. Manager Stephen Vogt had already exhausted six relievers before calling upon Smith in the eighth inning, forcing him to throw two more innings.

This decision may have implications for the team's strategy in Game 5, as Williams' availability as a starting pitcher is now in question. Having thrown 18 pitches in relief, he might not be able to go as deep into the game if needed. The Guardians were forced to use Parker Messick as an opener in Game 4.

Tanner Bibee, a traditional starter, has yet to pitch in the postseason and was instead used in relief in Game 4. His outing lasted only 15 pitches, but it's unclear whether he'll be available for another start. Foster Griffin, who threw 53 pitches in Game 3, may also be a factor in the team's pitching decisions.

The team's situation has been acknowledged by Noah Syndergaard, who expressed his willingness to adapt to whatever role is required of him. "I'm good to go," he said, indicating that he'll follow the lead of the coaching staff and do what's best for the team.

On the other hand, the White Sox have been building towards a potential showdown between their top pitchers in Game 5. Sean Burke has already shown his capabilities in the postseason, having worked 5 ⅓ innings without giving up a run in Game 2.

The Guardians will need to rely on their pitching depth to navigate the final game of the series and potentially send it back to Chicago for a decisive sixth game. Their ability to make adjustments and adapt to the circumstances may ultimately determine the outcome of this crucial matchup.

The Cleveland Guardians' comeback story is one for the ages, and it's not over yet. They've been given a new lease on life after stunning the Chicago White Sox in Game 4 of the ALDS, forcing a deciding Game 5.

This season, their ace pitcher had an impressive record of 11-7 with a 3.34 ERA and 185 strikeouts in 172 ⅓ innings, showcasing his dominance on the mound.

The Guardians' path to this moment has been anything but straightforward, with multiple lineup changes and pitching rotations making it difficult to predict what they'll face next. Despite the chaos, one thing is certain: the team's ability to adapt will be crucial in determining their fate.

In MLB history, there have been 10 instances where a team overcame a 2-0 deficit in a best-of-five series, with the most recent example being the Cleveland franchise itself in 2017. If they can pull off another stunning comeback, they'll join an elite group of teams that have achieved this feat.

The Guardians will look to write their own history and join the 2015 Blue Jays as the only team to overcome a 2-0 deficit by losing two home games and then winning two road games before closing out the series at home in Game 5.

Facts based on reporting originally published by CBS Sports.

You may republish this story, in full or in part, if you credit News Central Site and link to it (licence CC BY 4.0). Photos are not included.