ESPN’s Bill Barnwell released his annual ranking of NFL offensive playmaker groups…however you will need to perceive what he’s really rating earlier than anybody begins throwing issues at their display screen.
This is just not a rating of the most effective offenses in soccer.
Advertisement
Barnwell is trying strictly at every crew’s operating backs, broad receivers, and tight ends. His query is mainly this: If each crew had the identical quarterback, similar offensive line, similar play caller, similar damage luck (or unhealthy luck), and similar setup round them, which group of playmakers could be the most effective?
That issues rather a lot when speaking in regards to the Buffalo Bills.
Because Barnwell has the Bills ranked at No. 29 out of 32 groups. Only the Cleveland Browns, New York Giants, and Miami Dolphins completed behind Buffalo. That is a fairly tough spot for a crew that also has Super Bowl expectations, nevertheless it additionally says rather a lot about how a lot Josh Allen modifications the best way we view the roster. This rating removes Allen from the equation. It removes Joe Brady. It removes the offensive line. Once all of that’s stripped away, Barnwell clearly doesn’t love what Buffalo has round him.
He does give James Cook III credit score, and rightfully so. Cook has change into one of the most effective operating backs in soccer. The concern with Cook is the ball safety. Barnwell famous that Cook had six fumbles final season, plus one other within the playoff loss to the Denver Broncos. That is just not a small difficulty, particularly for a again who touches the ball as typically as Cook does.
Advertisement
After Cook, the questions begin piling up. The Bills added DJ Moore this offseason, however Barnwell is just not offered that Moore continues to be a real difference-maker as he will get nearer to 30. Khalil Shakir has settled in as a dependable slot receiver. Dalton Kincaid made the Pro Bowl and was extra environment friendly final season, however he nonetheless has not absolutely change into a high-volume reply many hoped he could be, and just lately well being and sturdiness issues have change into extra loud. Keon Coleman stays an enormous query mark, and regardless that it may not be honest to say with such a small dataset however Joshua Palmer could have gotten worse after becoming a member of the Bills. And Skyler Bell will stay an unknown till we see him in motion.
Interestingly, Barnwell had the Bills at No. 28 earlier than the 2025 marketing campaign and No. 24 in 2024.
That results in the identical query Bills followers have been asking for some time now. When Allen wants somebody to get open on the largest play of the sport, who’s the apparent reply? That is the place this rating stings.
For comparability, the Kansas City Chiefs got here in at No. 20, even after a disappointing season from their broad receivers. Rashee Rice and Xavier Worthy each include questions, and Travis Kelce is now not the automated TE1 choice he as soon as was, however the addition of Kenneth Walker III offers Kansas City extra explosiveness within the backfield.
Advertisement
The Baltimore Ravens landed at quantity 16 with Derrick Henry, Zay Flowers, and Mark Andrews nonetheless main the best way. Barnwell identified some issues there too, particularly with Henry’s age, fumbling points, and Andrews’ decline in manufacturing, however Baltimore nonetheless sits effectively forward of Buffalo.
Then there are the Cincinnati Bengals at quantity 3. That one is just not laborious to determine. Ja’Marr Chase and Tee Higgins give Cincinnati two receivers who can win as WR1 choices. Add Chase Brown to the combo, and the Bengals have the sort of high-end talent expertise Barnwell clearly appreciates.
The high 5 had been the Detroit Lions, Los Angeles Rams, Bengals, Atlanta Falcons, and San Francisco 49ers.
San Francisco may be probably the most attention-grabbing or controversial crew near the highest. Barnwell has them at No. 5 regardless of Christian McCaffrey, George Kittle, and Mike Evans all on the fallacious aspect of 30, and there are actual damage issues with that group. Still, the expertise is apparent.
Advertisement
That is de facto the distinction.
The Bills have good gamers. They have helpful gamers. They have gamers who match what Buffalo needs to do. But if you evaluate their group to groups with true game-changing broad receivers and tight ends, the hole continues to be there. Bills followers is not going to agree with No. 29, and that’s honest. It feels extraordinarily low for a crew that has remained one of the league’s most constant offenses. But the purpose of Barnwell’s train is to not rank what Buffalo’s offense might be with Allen at quarterback. It is asking what the playmakers appear like with out him on the sphere. Have the Bills executed sufficient to offer Allen a real go-to weapon when every part tightens up? Barnwell doesn’t appear to assume so.
The Bills’ offensive playmakers get one more season to show that No. 29 is manner too low.