New York
—
Coming out of the pandemic, many retail chains, political leaders, law enforcement officials and others advised America there was an unprecedented stage of shoplifting.
Shoplifting grew to become a political lighting rod, and movies of thieves smashing retailer home windows and grabbing merchandise rocketed across the news and social media as an emblem of a breakdown throughout cities.
But nationwide crime knowledge never showed a retail theft wave, although shoplifting did spike in sure cities like New York.
William Blair retail analysts in 2023 advised that chains had “overexaggerated” the affect, utilizing it as an excuse for stock mismanagement and strategic errors. Walgreens’ then-chief monetary officer even mentioned “maybe we cried too much” about misplaced merchandise and overspent on safety measures.
Retailers and officers are portray a a lot completely different image at the moment: They say their anti-theft methods and public coverage modifications are making an affect, and knowledge exhibits shoplifting charges are falling across the nation.
There are a number of causes for the shift in messaging and improved tendencies. For one, retailers’ instruments for monitoring merchandise grew to become extra correct lately. Cities and states devoted further assets to breaking apart organized theft rings. Lawmakers and voters permitted stiffer felony penalties for smaller ranges of theft and bigger organized crime. And firms tailored by investing in internal security—together with eradicating self-checkout stations and locking up merchandise to the purpose it turned off clients.
It’s a significant shift from the messaging simply two years in the past.
From 2021 to 2023, chains rallied public consideration to hovering ranges of theft and teams bursting into shops and grabbing cabinets stuffed with merchandise. Retailers closed in main cities, employed further safety, locked up merchandise behind glass instances and posted thousands and thousands of {dollars} in losses.
Target CEO Brian Cornell mentioned in 2023 that the chain was up in opposition to “an unacceptable amount of retail theft and organized retail crime.” More than 95% of shoplifting incidents contain one or two folks. But sporadic violent incidents of organized retail theft — bigger teams stealing merchandise with the intent to resell it— rattled the trade and made headlines.
Headline-making incidents apart, the imperfect knowledge accessible didn’t essentially again up a widespread pattern.
Overall, shoplifting incidents have been 16% greater within the first half of 2023 than the primary half of 2019, in accordance to an analysis by the Council on Criminal Justice, a nonpartisan felony justice coverage group. However, out of 24 cities the group analyzed, 17 reported decreases in shoplifting in that interval.
But the Council on Criminal Justice warns that shoplifting incidents usually go unreported, so the statistics “almost certainly undercount total shoplifting by a significant amount.”
That mentioned, knowledge from this yr present enhancements. Shoplifting experiences fell 12% on common throughout the first half of 2025 from the identical interval final yr, in accordance to the group.
In New York City, retail theft fell 12% yearly and 5% throughout the remainder of the state, Governor Kathy Hochul introduced final week. The drop got here after New York poured $40 million into legislation enforcement process forces devoted to investigating retail crime and handed laws permitting prosecutors to make it simpler to file felony fees for stealing merchandise from a number of shops.
“The numbers are excellent. This is a really good trend. I think you’re going to see it continue,” mentioned Christopher Herrmann, an assistant professor on the John Jay College of Criminal Justice.
Part of the muddiness within the knowledge is due to flaws within the measurements retailers use to calculate shoplifting and misplaced merchandise — however shops say that is enhancing shortly thanks to up to date processes and partnerships.
It’s inconceivable for retailers to know the precise trigger of each merchandise they lose. But their greatest estimate for objects that go lacking is a metric known as shrink charge: the tally of misplaced stock as a share of gross sales. The bulk of shrink is exterior theft and worker theft, but it surely additionally contains broken and spoiled merchandise, administrative errors, vendor fraud and different components.
Retailers have cautioned that shrink is an imperfect metric that doesn’t absolutely seize theft or organized crime, in addition to the affect of violence in opposition to staff, bodily harm to shops and buyer and worker perceptions of retailer security.
Still, many retailers have mentioned lately that their shrink charges are getting higher, pushed by their methods to forestall shoplifting and work with legislation enforcement.
“A couple of years ago we encountered a higher level of shrink in the business. We navigated that really well,” Walmart finance chief John David Rainey mentioned on a current earnings name. Target mentioned final month that its shrink charge this yr might be beneath pre-pandemic ranges.
Home Depot, too, has “seen measurable improvements in shrink,” significantly in areas the place the corporate has made focused investments and coordinated carefully with native prosecutors and legislation enforcement, the corporate’s vice chairman of asset safety Scott Glenn mentioned in a press release to NCS. “The external factors are not necessarily improving, but our efforts and are partnerships are working.”
Shrink charges are additionally enhancing as a result of retailers’ accounting of their merchandise has improved. Companies calculate their shrink charge based mostly on a bodily depend of their stock readily available, which most take a few times a yr, in accordance to the National Retail Federation, a prime lobbying group for the trade.
The pandemic additionally proved to be a confounding issue throughout that 2021 to 2023 interval. Shrink dipped in 2020 as shops closed throughout the pandemic and clients shopped on-line — after which, as shops started reopening, retailers underestimated their shrink charge.
When shops took bodily inventories in 2022, they have been lacking extra merchandise than they anticipated, so that they elevated their shrink estimate and took a steeper hit to revenue.
Now, they are saying their shrink charges are falling from these ranges.
Measurement nuances usually are not the one change, nevertheless. Public insurance policies, nearer retailer collaboration with legislation enforcement to thwart theft, and different investments have additionally made a distinction within the trade’s struggle.
Over the final 4 years, states have handed greater than 80 legal guidelines centered on stopping organized retail crime, in accordance to the trade group International Council of Shopping Centers. These legal guidelines have had the backing of the retail trade and lots of legislation enforcement teams.
At first, the trade and legislation enforcement officers centered on organized networks reselling stolen items on on-line marketplaces comparable to Amazon and Facebook. In 2022, Congress handed the Inform Consumers Act requiring on-line marketplaces to accumulate and confirm details about third-party sellers.
They additionally pushed to decrease thresholds for prosecutors to cost folks with felony thefts and require stiffer sentences for repeat offenders. Tougher felony insurance policies might not deter crime, nevertheless. Laws and insurance policies designed to deter crime by focusing primarily on growing the severity of punishments are ineffective, in accordance to the Department of Justice. “Research shows clearly that the chance of being caught is a vastly more effective deterrent than even draconian punishment.”
Jurisdictions have elevated funding and personnel for legislation enforcement to examine organized retail crime instances.
“We have seen states and communities step up against organized retail crime,” mentioned David Johnston, vice chairman of asset safety and retail operations for the National Retail Federation. “There has been progress made at local, state and federal level.”
Home Depot’s Scott Glenn mentioned that the corporate’s shut coordination with legislation enforcement helps lead to bigger instances in opposition to organized teams, together with 14 folks arrested final month allegedly linked to 600 thefts at 71 completely different shops in Southern California. Home Depot mentioned it was the most important retail theft case in its historical past.
The trade needs extra to be completed on organized retail crime and has promoted a bipartisan federal invoice, the Combating Organized Retail Crime Act, to create a nationwide process power to give attention to advanced felony enterprises that cross state traces.
“It’s an essential piece of the puzzle,” Glenn mentioned.