New York
—
Unless your identify is Domino’s, it’s robust to be a pizza chain proper now.
Just ask their two fundamental opponents: Pizza Hut and Papa Johns. The former has posted eight consecutive quarters of gross sales declines and may be on the block. The latter is within the midst of an intensive turnaround effort to lure clients back after a dismal two years.
Part of that effort for Papa Johns is bringing back the Pan Pizza, a menu merchandise it hasn’t supplied in a decade.
“The pandemic burned people out on so much pizza to a degree,” mentioned Robert Byrne, senior director of client analysis for Technomic. In its place, clients, particularly youthful eaters, are turning to “interesting” cuisines, like fried chicken or specialty drinks.
Pizza can also be now not the go-to on the subject of supply. The rise lately of third-party supply apps, like DoorDash or Uber Eats, has allowed clients to browse and choose completely different cuisines, he added.
That’s all brought on hassle for the foremost pizza chains. Sales are anticipated to be flat this 12 months, remaining at $31 billion for 2025, in response to Technomic.
For customers, value supersedes high quality — even when Papa Johns claims it has a greater product or Pizza Hut seems to supply extra toppings, he added. Also, the chains have hiked costs over the previous few years due to rising prices.
“It’s still pizza,” Byrne advised NCS. “The lower price here is what’s appealing.”
Domino’s has figured that out: Its $9.99 “Best Deal Ever” promotion final summer time was profitable, serving to the chain’s gross sales soar 5.4% in its most up-to-date quarter.
Papa Johns struggles transcend pricing, Byrne mentioned, tracing back to an absence of menu innovation. The chain’s CEO, former Wendy’s govt Todd Penegor, was employed in 2024 to assist repair its choices and hopefully engineer a turnaround.
Penegor first simplified the menu by lowering the number of non-core items after which recalibrated the eating places’ ovens to make sure higher cooking.
His subsequent large activity is innovation, beginning with Wednesday’s announcement of the Pan Pizza. The chain hopes the nostalgia-inducing item brings in clients who mentioned that competitor’s variations aren’t satisfying.
“They remember what pan pizza used to be, which doesn’t match what the category is today,” Shivram Vaideeswaran, Papa Johns’ vp of promoting, advised NCS. “We didn’t want to just be the best kind of pizza, but we really wanted to be the best pan pizza, period.”
The 12-inch pizza, which is topped with six cheeses that stretches to the sting and may maintain as much as seven toppings, goes on sale February 3 for $11.99.
Sales at Papa Johns in the latest quarter declined 3%. The chain hopes the Pan Pizza not solely attracts new clients but additionally provides its present clientele another excuse to decide on them over its opponents, Vaideeswaran mentioned.
Byrne mentioned {that a} new pizza has “potential” to enhance gross sales and ideally visits, which has slipped almost 6% year-over-year.
However, he mentioned Papa Johns has a number of work to do with its aspect dishes and appetizers. The chain’s choices aren’t bought as often as its opponents.
“A new pizza has a price premium that’s going to be placed on it and so there’s a little more of a risk involved from a consumers’ perspective,” he mentioned. Cheaper appetizers and sides, compared, are a “low-risk venture” in bringing people back.