NCS
—
When you consider Tokyo, you would possibly consider neon-lit skyscrapers and its world-famous bullet prepare system, or movies like “Akira” and “Ghost in the Shell” that depict a futuristic Japan stuffed with clever robots and holograms.
But there’s a extra mundane aspect of Japan that you just gained’t discover anyplace in these cyberpunk movies. It entails fax machines, floppy disks and customized ink stamps – relics which have lengthy died out in different superior nations however have stubbornly persisted in Japan.
For on a regular basis residents, the lag in digital expertise and the following paperwork is at finest inconvenient, and at worst makes you need to tear your hair out.
“Japanese banks are portals to hell,” one Facebook person wrote in a native expat group. A commenter joked sarcastically: “Maybe sending a fax would help.”
The scale of the issue turned terrifyingly clear through the Covid-19 pandemic, because the Japanese authorities struggled to reply to a nationwide disaster with clumsy digital instruments.
In the years since, they’ve launched a devoted effort to shut that hole, together with a newly created Digital Agency and a host of latest initiatives. But they’re arriving to the tech race many years late – 36 years after the arrival of the World Wide Web, and greater than half a century after the primary ever electronic mail was despatched.
Now because the nation races to rework itself, the query stays: What took them so lengthy, and can they nonetheless catch up?
It wasn’t at all times this fashion. Japan was the article of world admiration within the Nineteen Seventies and ‘80s, when corporations like Sony, Toyota, Panasonic and Nintendo turned family names. Japan introduced the world beloved units just like the Walkman, and video games like Donkey Kong and Mario Bros.
But that modified by the flip of the century with the rise of computer systems and the web.
While the world was shifting to software-driven economies, “Japan, with its strengths in hardware, was slow to adapt to software and services,” mentioned Daisuke Kawai, director of the University of Tokyo’s Economic Security and Policy Innovation Program.
A spread of things exacerbated the issue, he mentioned. Japan didn’t make investments sufficient in data and communications expertise, and as its electronics business shrank, Japanese engineers flocked to international corporations.
That left a authorities with low digital literacy and a lack of expert tech employees. Over time, totally different ministries and companies adopted their very own patchwork IT methods, however there was by no means a unified authorities push – which means public providers by no means correctly modernized and remained reliant on paper paperwork and hand-carved, customized seals referred to as hanko which might be used for identification verification.
There have been cultural components, too.
“Japanese companies are known for their risk-averse culture, seniority-based … hierarchical system, and a slow, consensus-driven decision-making process – all of which hampered innovation,” Kawai mentioned.
And thanks to Japan’s plummeting birthrate, it has much more previous folks than younger folks. This outsized aged proportion meant a wider mistrust of latest applied sciences, wariness of digital fraud, a desire for conventional strategies just like the hanko, and “relatively little demand or pressure for digital services,” Kawai mentioned.
That apathy was widespread, mentioned Jonathan Coopersmith, professor emeritus of historical past at Texas A&M University. Small companies and people didn’t really feel compelled to change from fax machines to computer systems: Why purchase costly new equipment and learn the way to use it, when fax labored wonderful and all people in Japan used it anyway?
Larger companies and establishments like banks or hospitals discovered a potential change too disruptive to day by day providers. “The bigger you are, the harder it is to change, especially software,” mentioned Coopersmith, who wrote about Japan’s relationship with the fax machine in a 2015 e-book concerning the machine.
It additionally posed a authorized headache. Any new expertise requires new legal guidelines – for example, how electrical scooters prompted new street rules, or how nations worldwide at the moment are making an attempt to legislate in opposition to deepfakes and AI copyright after the AI growth. Digitizing Japan would have required altering hundreds of rules, Coopersmith estimates – and lawmakers merely had no incentive to accomplish that. After all, it’s not like digitization is a key difficulty driving votes in elections.
He summed it up: “Why do I want to become part of the digital world if I don’t need to?”
The pandemic push
The end result was that for many years, Japan remained stuck with previous tech whilst it progressed in different methods – creating the last word contradiction.
Japan has world-class robotics and aerospace industries, and options of day-to-day life that have a tendency to awe international vacationers, like secure and clear public areas, ubiquitous merchandising machines and comfort shops, broadly accessible public transit and a complete bullet prepare system.
Its digital failings look much more stark by comparability.
In 2018, Japan’s then cybersecurity minister sparked outrage and disbelief when he claimed he’d never used a computer since his secretaries did “that kind of thing” – earlier than strolling again his remarks a few days later.
And it wasn’t till 2019 that the last company in Japan nonetheless working pagers lastly halted providers – many years after the non-public messaging machine was rendered out of date by cell telephones.
The prevalence of previous expertise additionally created infinite paperwork. Opening a checking account or registering for housing would possibly require a hanko seal, alongside with paperwork of non-public data you may have to go to a native council to request in particular person, mentioned Kawai.
In the top, it took a world pandemic to lastly power change. Japan’s technological hole turned evident as nationwide and native authorities turned overwhelmed, with out the digital instruments to streamline their processes.
It was solely in May 2020, months after the virus started working rampant globally, that Japan’s well being ministry launched an online portal for hospitals to report circumstances as a substitute of counting on handwritten faxes, telephone calls or emails.
And even then, hiccups persevered. A contact tracing app had a months-long system error that failed to notify folks of doable publicity, reported public broadcaster NHK. Adjusting to distant work and college was robust, as many had by no means used file-sharing providers or video tools like Zoom.
In one mind-boggling case in 2022, a Japanese city by chance wired the whole lot of its Covid reduction fund – about 46.3 million yen ($322,000) – to only one man’s checking account. The confusion stemmed from the financial institution being given each a floppy disk of knowledge and a paper request kind – however by the point authorities realized their error, the person had already gambled away many of the funds, in accordance to NHK.
For anybody underneath 35, a floppy disk is a magnetic reminiscence strip encased in plastic that is bodily inserted into a laptop. Each one sometimes shops up to 1.44MB of knowledge – lower than an average-resolution picture in your iPhone.
The state of affairs acquired so dangerous that at one level, Takuya Hirai – who in 2021 was appointed to the newly created function of Minister of Digital Transformation – described the nation’s dealing with of the pandemic as a “digital defeat.”
Thus, the Digital Agency was born – a division tasked with bringing Japan up to velocity, born from a “combination of fear and opportunity,” mentioned Coopersmith.
Created in 2021, it launched a collection of initiatives together with rolling out a sensible model of Japan’s social safety card and pushing for extra cloud-based infrastructure.
Last July, the Digital Agency lastly declared victory in its “war on floppy disks,” eliminating the disks throughout all authorities programs – a mammoth effort that required scrapping greater than 1,000 rules governing their use.
But there have been rising pains, too. At one level, the federal government requested the general public for his or her ideas concerning the metaverse – by a convoluted system that required downloading an Excel spreadsheet, filling out your particulars, and emailing the doc again to the ministry, local media reported.
After the transfer garnered scorn and disbelief on social media, then Digital Minister Taro Kono wrote on Twitter: “The (ministry) will respond properly using an (online) form from now on.”
With the federal government firmly forging ahead, corporations hastened to comply with, many hiring exterior contractors and consultants to assist overhaul their programs, mentioned Kawai.
Masahiro Goto is one such guide. As a part of the Nomura Research Institute’s (NRI) digital transformation staff, he has helped massive Japanese corporations throughout all industries adapt to the digital world – from designing new enterprise fashions to adopting new inside programs.
These shoppers are sometimes “eager to move forward, but they’re unsure how to go about it,” he informed NCS. “Many are still using old systems that require a lot of maintenance, or systems that are approaching end-of-service life. In many cases, that’s when they reach out to us for help.”
The NRI consultants are in excessive demand – the variety of corporations reaching out for his or her providers “has definitely been rising year by year,” particularly within the final 5 years, Goto mentioned. And for good purpose: for years, Japanese corporations outsourced their IT wants, which means they now lack the in-house abilities to absolutely digitize.
“Fundamentally, they want to make their operations more efficient, and I believe they want to actively adopt digital technologies as a means of survival,” he mentioned. “After all, Japan’s population is going to continue to decline, so improving productivity is essential.”
There might be resistance in sure pockets – the Digital Agency’s plan to get rid of fax machines inside the authorities obtained 400 formal objections from totally different ministries in 2021, according to local media.
Things just like the hanko seal – that are rooted in custom and customized, and which some dad and mom reward to their kids after they come of age – might be more durable to part out given their cultural significance.
The tempo of progress additionally will depend on how prepared the Digital Agency is to push regulatory reform, and how a lot lawmakers will prioritize digitization in creating future budgets, Kawai mentioned. There’s additionally the very fact Japan is taking part in catch-up with transferring goalposts, as new applied sciences surge ahead in different elements of the world.
“This is going to be an ongoing challenge because the digital technologies of 2025 are going to be different from the ones of 2030, 2035,” mentioned Coopersmith.
But specialists are optimistic. Kawai estimates at this price, Japan may catch up with some Western friends in 5 to 10 years.
And lastly, there’s a public starvation for it, with extra and extra companies accepting cashless funds and rolling out new on-line providers.
“People are generally eager to digitize for sure,” mentioned Kawai. “I’m sure that young people, or the general public, prefer to digitize as fast as possible.”