Chandler, Arizona
—
Andy and Carrie Hoefer knew little about knowledge facilities till a discover arrived informing them that one is likely to be constructed throughout the avenue from their condominium advanced.
Only then did they make a startling discovery: Ten knowledge facilities already function in the space round their dwelling.
“Do we really need 11?” Andy Hoefer requested.
The metropolis of Chandler has spent years wrestling with that query, simply as communities round the nation debate the financial and environmental trade-offs of those hulking, resource-intensive warehouses of servers and different IT gear that energy every thing from streaming providers to on-line banking
In battleground Arizona and past, the politics of data centers are unsettled, not falling neatly alongside partisan traces. And President Donald Trump has injected himself into the fights, throwing the full weight of his administration behind winning the artificial intelligence race by no matter means attainable — together with fast-tracking knowledge facilities.
Chandler, for its half, determined three years in the past it didn’t want one other knowledge middle. After a decade of noise complaints and rising worries about dwindling water provides and surging electrical payments, Chandler turned considered one of the first cities in the nation to undertake restrictions designed to make opening knowledge facilities far tougher. The ordinance despatched a transparent sign to sure expertise corporations to rethink enlargement in the fast-growing Phoenix suburb.
Now, a developer has proposed a facility that’s anticipated to be extra highly effective than any knowledge middle already working in Chandler. The firm argues the venture — a $2.5 billion expertise park anchored by an information middle so long as a soccer area and seven tales high — would place the metropolis at the forefront of a man-made intelligence increase, attracting new companies and bringing renewed status to considered one of the state’s most dynamic technological engines.
Chandler metropolis employees have advisable towards it, warning knowledge facilities traditionally convey few jobs and many issues. The developer, nevertheless, has enlisted a high-profile advocate: former Arizona Sen. Kyrsten Sinema, a Democrat-turned-independent who’s intently aligned with Trump’s AI offensive. Sinema lately cautioned metropolis officers that the Trump administration may sometime pressure an information middle on them in the event that they block this one. The City Council is scheduled to vote on the measure Thursday.
Residents are pushing again. Emails opposing the new knowledge middle outnumber supporters by greater than 20-to-1, in response to a City Council memo. Andy Hoefer, a 65-year-old monetary planner, designed and despatched greater than 2,000 submit playing cards to neighbors to boost consciousness, whereas Carrie, a 63-year-old registered nurse, knocked on a whole lot of doorways to rally opposition.
“I’m not against AI; I think it’s great,” she stated. “But I don’t want to become a subject in a future study on what it’s like to live in such close proximity to so many data centers.”
Chandler didn’t got down to turn out to be an information middle hub. Once lined in cattle, cotton and ostrich farms, the valley metropolis’s inhabitants exploded after Intel opened a manufacturing facility in 1980. Other blue-chip companies, similar to Wells Fargo, Northrop Grumman and Microchip Technology, adopted. Chandler is now a key cog in the rise of Arizona’s Silicon Desert.
Then, a developer’s post-Great Recession plan to show an previous Motorola facility right into a 152-acre expertise park didn’t materialize. The preliminary proposal referred to as for only one knowledge middle, former City Councilmember Rick Heumann stated, however when tenants didn’t arrive, extra knowledge facilities crammed the empty land. By 2023, when the metropolis’s new guidelines on knowledge facilities went into impact, 10 had arrange in Chandler’s fundamental company hall.
“There’s like no jobs to speak of,” Heumann stated, bristling at the fortified buildings as he drove by on a latest Thursday morning.
The metropolis estimates that the tech park employs fewer than 100 individuals and that knowledge facilities in normal convey “extremely low employment per square foot” in contrast with different industries, Chandler employees wrote in one presentation.
Cepand Alizadeh, the authorities relations director for the pro-data middle Arizona Technology Council, argued that these services create hundreds of building jobs and that the full-time positions supply aggressive salaries and engaging advantages.
“For every one job at a data center, six other jobs are created in a local ecosystem,” Alizadeh stated.
For years, residents complained of droning sounds coming from the services. Abatement efforts have lessened the burden, however locals nonetheless chime in on neighborhood Facebook teams when these services loudly check their backup mills. The native electrical utility, Salt River Project, constructed further substations and utility traces close by simply to service the knowledge facilities. Concerns about water used to chill these buildings habitually arose in the desert neighborhood.
But Adam Baugh, an Arizona lawyer representing the venture, says it’s unfair to match their proposal for a man-made intelligence knowledge middle to these already working in the metropolis. This one, they contend, will entice corporations desirous to arrange store subsequent to their cutting-edge expertise, and they’ve promised to construct 5 further buildings to deal with future tenants.
“Calling this a data center is like comparing a Walkman and an iPhone and saying they’re both musical devices,” Baugh lately informed the metropolis. He didn’t reply to emails from NCS.
The developer of the new venture, Jeff Zygler of EnergeticInfrastructure, didn’t reply to a request for remark.
Already this 12 months, the knowledge middle debate has echoed by means of statehouses and formed key races. Georgia voters final month ousted two Republicans from the state utility board in response to hovering electrical charges blamed in half on knowledge facilities. That identical night time, Virginia Gov.-elect Abigail Spanberger vowed to “make sure that data centers pay their fair share” in her victory speech.
Both events anticipate the subject will floor in the midterm elections as Democrats sharpen their message on rising energy payments and different affordability challenges and as Republicans brace for an citizens more and more attuned to the prices of Trump’s AI agenda.
The politics round knowledge facilities are “still emerging,” in half as a result of hyperscalers are so new and builders are dashing to construct them in so many locations, stated Harvard University sociology professor Jason Beckfield, who’s finding out knowledge facilities.
“A lot of people feel like these things drop from the sky,” Beckfield informed NCS. “The developers are under huge pressure to get these things done as fast as humanly possible.”
Data facilities like the one proposed in Chandler are a key pillar of Trump’s plan to beat China and turn out to be the main AI superpower. Under an AI motion plan launched in July, the White House advisable easing federal guidelines and expediting permits to assemble knowledge facilities.
Against that backdrop, Sinema lately raised eyebrows by suggesting Chandler’s selections in the future could also be restricted.
“Federal preemption is coming,” she stated at the metropolis’s October zoning assembly. “Chandler right now has the opportunity to determine how and when these new, innovative AI data centers will be built. When federal preemption comes, you will no longer have that privilege.”
Sinema launched herself as the co-chair of the newly shaped AI Infrastructure Coalition, an trade group she based shortly after leaving Congress. She informed NCS she has a contract with the firm constructing the Chandler venture, a truth she didn’t share throughout her public remarks. Emails obtained by NCS by means of a public data request present Sinema assembly with metropolis leaders to debate the knowledge middle since midsummer.
The former Arizona senator informed the board she works “hand in glove with the Trump administration,” and her remarks have been extensively interpreted as a risk from Washington. The White House didn’t reply to a request for remark.
Her look attracted native information protection and appeared to accentuate opposition. In emails despatched to City Hall after the zoning assembly, residents repeatedly referenced Sinema’s statements and some informed NCS they weren’t conscious of the knowledge middle venture earlier than her involvement turned publicized.
“It wasn’t a threat, it was a promise,” stated Councilmember OD Harris. “People are fired up over this now, and they’re fired up because of Sen. Sinema. She shouldn’t have come.”
Cities are more and more involved that Sinema foreshadowed a looming battle. Trump’s allies are already laying the groundwork for his administration to overrule native guidelines to construct the infrastructure supporting AI enlargement, stated Angelina Panettieri, who tracks expertise laws for the National League of Cities. In pushing forward with Trump’s AI motion plan, the Federal Communications Commission, for instance, has mentioned whether or not cities and counties have laws that “could inhibit U.S. leadership in evolving technologies like artificial intelligence.”
In an interview this week, Sinema stated her remarks have been misconstrued.
“I believe in local control,” she stated.
Massive energy calls for
Tech corporations’ race to dominate synthetic intelligence is quickly reworking communities throughout the nation.
Virginia has the largest knowledge middle cluster in not simply the US, however the complete world. Texas and Ohio are changing into main hubs, too. But tech corporations are wanting west — more and more, towards Arizona.
The state’s desert panorama, though punishingly scorching, is comparatively flat and not vulnerable to disasters like hurricanes, floods or earthquakes. It’s additionally financially engaging: A beneficiant state tax credit score exempts corporations from paying state or native taxes on their laptop gear inside the buildings.
But native officers are rising more and more uncomfortable with the energy and useful resource calls for from knowledge facilities. Arizona is a water-scarce state whose share of the Colorado River is dwindling at the identical time farms are pumping vast amounts of groundwater to develop greens and forage crops in the desert.
Some knowledge facilities use water to chill their stacks of overheating laptop servers, however corporations — together with the builder behind the Chandler venture — are extra more likely to suggest “dry cooling,” primarily utilizing air con as a substitute of water. That could also be excellent news for water assets, but it surely means knowledge facilities want much more electrical energy to maintain cool.
Trump has publicly instructed that US energy manufacturing should double to fulfill the calls for to win America’s AI race towards different nations. A 2024 report by the US Department of Energy estimated that knowledge facilities would devour between 6.7% and 12% of the nation’s electrical energy by 2028.
The two main utilities serving Arizona acknowledged receiving eye-popping electrical energy requests from knowledge facilities. As demand has elevated, so too have Arizona’s electrical energy prices. One utility, Arizona Public Service, this summer season requested the Arizona Corporation Commission to approve a 16% fee hike.
There is mounting shopper frustration that value spikes are linked to the knowledge facilities. Arizona Public Service spokesperson Ann Porter stated the requested fee hike “doesn’t include costs of infrastructure that might be needed to be built in the future to serve data center customers.” Industry teams have contended electrical prices are rising in all places, even in locations with out knowledge facilities.
Still, utilities are now charging tech corporations up-front for the large quantities of electrical energy they wish to use to make sure residents aren’t caught with the invoice. For the proposed knowledge middle in Chandler, the Salt River Project, the native utility, is requiring the developer to pay $242 million to cowl the prices to construct further capability.
The quantity of electrical energy knowledge facilities are requesting is almost equal to the Salt River Project’s present energy capability, stated utility spokesperson Jennifer Schuricht — and it’s going to take constructing new energy crops and infrastructure to fulfill it.
Forecasting how a lot energy to plan for is an inexact science — particularly when the estimates from knowledge facilities seem like wildly inflated, stated Kelly Barr, affiliate vice chairman at Arizona State University’s Global Futures Laboratory and a former govt at the Salt River Project. And in Arizona, the place air conditioners are the distinction between life and demise throughout summer season months, the penalties of guessing flawed are dire.
Ensuring the grid runs reliably is utilities’ “top priority,” Barr stated.
“If that means data centers are served a bit later, then that’s simply what has to happen,” she added.
A 6-foot wall is all that separates Patrick Griffith’s yard from his metropolis’s explosive development.
Through triple-pane home windows, the 61-year-old retired insurance coverage adjuster can nonetheless hear the visitors from a highway resulting in an ever-expanding Intel plant. His ficus tree can’t totally disguise the energy traces that ship electrical energy throughout the desert into power-hungry tech hubs. Some nights, the stench from a close-by water therapy plant spoils plans to dine on his patio.
But it’s the knowledge middle deliberate for throughout the avenue from his wall that will lastly push him out of his two-story dwelling after three many years.
“My wife has been ready to go for some time,” Griffith stated. “If they build this, I may give in.”
While outnumbered, advocates for the venture are quietly hoping for fulfillment. Chris Tiller, an area actual property agent, is anxious the metropolis is just too dedicated to an getting old mannequin depending on giant firms constructing large workplaces on vacant land.
“It’s 2026. Adapt or die,” Tiller stated at a latest City Hall listening session on knowledge facilities.
Zygler, the developer, has not in public remarks recognized potential customers of the knowledge middle or the corporations which may transfer subsequent door. Zygler additionally couldn’t level to an analogous venture working in the state, although he stated two are beneath building. That worries some metropolis officers who keep in mind the final decade all too nicely.
“I’ve asked them: ‘Can you tell me this is not a ‘Field of Dreams’ scenario where you build it and hope they come?’” stated Councilmember Matt Orlando. “If they want a vote from me, they need to give me some answers.”