Washington
—
The household of a person killed in January’s midair collision near Washington, DC, is suing American Airlines, regional jet operator PSA Airlines, and the federal government, in line with a lawsuit filed Wednesday.
Rachel Crafton, whose husband Casey was on the passenger aircraft, filed the swimsuit alleging wrongful dying and negligence.
It’s the first federal lawsuit for the collision that killed 67 individuals when an Army Black Hawk helicopter and American Eagle flight 5342 collided over the Potomac River.
“It was predictable, it was preventable, and it caused the needless loss of 67 lives,” Bob Clifford, the legal professional main the swimsuit, mentioned at a press convention in Washington, DC, Wednesday.
The lawsuit alleges the defendants knew or ought to have recognized that airport approaches at one among the busiest airspaces in the United States “presented certain safety risks, specifically including the possibility of a midair collision.”
The National Transportation Safety Board’s investigation has not but decided a possible trigger for the collision, however the company has highlighted a number of points that probably contributed to the deadliest US aviation catastrophe in almost 1 / 4 century.
“American had the ability, because of their notice of near misses, a massive number of near misses, that they nevertheless allowed their customers to be exposed to the danger associated with those near misses,” Clifford mentioned. “They sought additional gates, they sought additional landings and takeoffs.”
The Army helicopter flew too excessive, and pilots of each plane “utterly failed in their responsibilities” to see and keep away from the different plane, the lawsuit says.
Investigators discovered the Army helicopter was flying 100 ft above its most allowed altitude of 200 ft at the time of the collision and it’s altimeter might not have been correct.
After the crash, the NTSB discovered data of 15,214 “near miss events” at the airport between 2021 and 2024, the place plane have been inside one nautical mile of one another, with a vertical separation of lower than 400 ft. There have been additionally 85 circumstances the place plane have been a lot nearer – lower than 1,500 ft aside, with a vertical separation of lower than 200 ft, in line with the NTSB.
American Airlines “manipulated and abused” the arrival price system so as to add extra flights per hour, “despite its knowledge that doing so severely limited the margins for safety,” the swimsuit alleges.
American responded to the lawsuit, saying it continues to “mourn the lives lost in the tragic accident,” however that the blame rests with the army.
“Flight 5342 was on a routine approach to DCA when the Army helicopter — that was above the published helicopter route altitude — collided with it,” the airline mentioned. “We continue to support the ongoing NTSB investigation and will defend American and PSA Airlines against any legal action claiming the airline caused or contributed to this accident.”
The Army declined to touch upon the swimsuit, saying its major focus stays on supporting the households of the victims and guaranteeing the security of troopers and the public.
“Out of respect for the deceased, their families, and the ongoing investigation, it is inappropriate for the Army to comment on litigation,” they mentioned in a press release.
The swimsuit additionally faults the Federal Aviation Administration for permitting the congested airspace to exist and the actions of controllers.
“The primary duty of an air traffic controller is to separate traffic and to avoid midair collisions. In this particular case they completely failed to meet that responsibility,” legal professional Brian Alexander mentioned.
In a press release to NCS, the FAA highlighted quite a few adjustments made at the airport since the collision, together with eliminating blended helicopter and airplane site visitors, modified helicopter zones, and elevated staffing.
“Our hearts go out to the families who lost loved ones on that tragic January evening,” the company mentioned. “We will continue to work closely with the NTSB to ensure no family has to suffer this pain again.”
The lawsuit additionally mentions the passenger jet pilots’ flight maneuvers and resolution to just accept air site visitors management’s supply to land on the “more difficult” runway 33, regardless of planning to land on runway 1.
“I actually don’t wish to, however I assume uhhh inform ‘em—,” the captain told the first officer, according to the lawsuit. “Its fine, we got the numbers… we’ll do 33.”
Tim Lilley, father of the first officer, Sam Lilley, launched a press release explaining the household didn’t take part in the lawsuit or subsequent press convention.
“Everyone who lost a loved one in the January 29 accident has the right to pursue the path they feel is best,” Lilley mentioned. “We respect those choices while standing united in the shared goal of making sure no family ever suffers through such a preventable tragedy again.”
The NTSB’s remaining report on the collision is anticipated when the investigation concludes in January.
A ‘devoted father and husband’
Casey Crafton, whose spouse Rachel filed the lawsuit Wednesday, was a “devoted father and husband,” she mentioned in a press release learn by his brother.
“Our lives were shattered in a moment, and the grief has been unimaginable, she said. “The future we dreamed about was taken away from us.”
Casey had a profession in aviation, first as a mechanic and then as a technical service supervisor.
“Casey was betrayed by this system he trusted,” she mentioned. “We are taking legal action because the accountability of American Airlines, PSA Airlines, and the Army and FAA is the only way to ensure this never happens again and no other family has to live with the pain we have to endure each day without Casey.”
The lawsuit seeks unspecified financial damages.
Clifford says he expects the households of most different passengers may even sue, however they need to wait as a consequence of guidelines governing discover given when a swimsuit is filed against the federal government.
Doug Lane, whose spouse and son have been killed in the collision, mentioned he was at as we speak’s press convention to help the Crafton household.
“Many of us have been asked us whether we dread rehashing the worst days of our lives in court. Our answer today is clear, ‘we are ready,’” he mentioned. “Nothing will help the healing process more than seeing the negligence, bureaucracy run amuck and the instances of putting corporate profits over public safety on full display.”
This summer season, the NTSB held three days of hearings to analyze the possible reason behind the crash. The hearings lined audio discovered from the incident in the Army helicopter, air traffic control training and key organizational structures that will have led to the lethal incident.
Prior to the NTSB’s investigation, lawmakers had known as the Federal Aviation Administration, NTSB and Army to Capitol Hill to testify. The Army’s position in the crash had lengthy been some extent of dialogue since the incident, and families of the victims felt as though they didn’t hear from the Army enough.
In July, Sen. Ted Cruz, chairman of the Senate Commerce, Science and Transportation Committee, introduced a bill that might require plane operators to put in key anti-collision know-how on all flights and require the Army to maintain it turned on in virtually each case. The helicopter that collided with the passenger aircraft was not broadcasting ADS-B monitoring knowledge as a consequence of a rule that allowed the Army to fly with the system turned off.
NCS’s Brian Todd contributed to this report.