Latest
Wednesday, November 18, 2026
  • New YorkNY
  • LondonLDN
  • TokyoTYO
Business

Alfozan Faces Espionage Allegations Without Concrete Evidence

Federal prosecutors have yet to find any evidence linking Abdulrahman Alfozan to espionage or trade secret theft.

DOJ says it hasn't yet found any evidence of Saudi espionage in case against OpenAI engineer
Source: Business Insider

Federal prosecutors have revealed that they have yet to find any evidence linking Abdulrahman Alfozan, a Saudi national and former OpenAI engineer, to espionage or trade secret theft.

Alfozan was arrested in mid-October for allegedly planting a listening device at the company's San Francisco office, where he had been working as an engineer. His lawyer, David Rizk, has maintained that his client is innocent of these charges.

During Tuesday's court hearing, Rizk argued that if there were sufficient evidence to support the espionage allegations, new charges would have been brought against Alfozan when he was initially indicted. Instead, the prosecution has provided no concrete evidence to substantiate their claims.

In a filing ahead of the hearing, Rizk noted that the government had floated the idea that Alfozan was a spy, yet failed to provide any supporting evidence.

A grand jury indictment against Alfozan was brought in October, but it didn't include severe charges such as espionage or theft of trade secrets. This decision has raised eyebrows given the initial claims made by prosecutors during the hearing that resulted in his continued detention. The prosecution had hinted at additional charges being filed, which has yet to materialize.

Judge Chhabria expressed concerns about the prosecution's overpromising in October, suggesting they may have gotten ahead of themselves. He is now scrutinizing their actions and questioning whether they have sufficient evidence to support their claims. The judge wants to ensure that the prosecution doesn't make promises it cannot keep.

The investigation is ongoing, with prosecutors still reviewing 160 hours of audio recordings that appear to be from meetings at OpenAI. They are also examining Alfozan's and his wife's computers as well as video footage from the company. However, a power outage at an FBI facility had previously locked Alfozan's cellphone, hindering investigators' ability to create a full forensic image.

Parker revealed that Alfozan eventually agreed to provide the password for his phone after the hearing, allowing investigators to access its contents. Additionally, the prosecution is unable to access the current contents of the recording device allegedly placed by Alfozan due to it being encrypted.

The prosecution's case against OpenAI engineer Ali Alfozan has yet to uncover any evidence linking him to Saudi espionage or economic espionage. However, defense attorney Parker is growing increasingly frustrated with the pace of evidence delivery. He claims that the prosecution has been slow in providing critical information needed for his client's defense.

Judge Chhabria has intervened, urging the prosecution to expedite its efforts and provide additional material, including footage from OpenAI and reports compiled by FBI agents working on the case. This includes accessing the contents of Alfozan's laptops, which are allegedly encrypted. The judge emphasized the importance of timely delivery to avoid further delays.

Parker has expressed concerns that Rizk may be using a competitor's AI model to sift through discovery documents containing OpenAI data found on Alfozan's devices. However, Judge Chhabria seems less concerned about this possibility, downplaying it with a dry remark. Despite the lighthearted exchange, the judge remains focused on moving the case forward.

The court has set several deadlines to keep the case on track: by December 8, the prosecution and defense must reach an agreement on AI usage; discovery submissions are due on December 11; and trial is scheduled to begin the week of January 19.

The judge's decision to keep Alfozan in jail has raised concerns about the case's progression. Parker believes that Rizk will attempt to delay the trial once he receives evidence related to Saudi espionage. This move could potentially hinder the trial's momentum.

Alfozan's bond was offered by the Saudi government, and his wife and son have already relocated to Saudi Arabia, which led a previous judge to rule that there is a high risk of him fleeing if released. These factors contributed to the decision to keep Alfozan in custody while awaiting trial. The court has taken steps to ensure the case remains on track.

Photos included in Alfozan's complaint show a USB device hidden behind a conference room TV, wrapped in toilet paper, and another image of Alfozan checking on the device after it was discovered. These images are part of the evidence presented by prosecutors in the case against Alfozan.

Facts based on reporting originally published by Business Insider.

You may republish this story, in full or in part, if you credit News Central Site and link to it (licence CC BY 4.0). Photos are not included.