---
title: "Peter S Alagona, Ursus arctos horribilis"
url: https://newscentral.site/peter-s-alagona-ursus-arctos-horribilis/
language: en
publisher: "News Central Site"
section: "Science"
published: 2026-11-17T11:11:52.000Z
updated: 2026-11-17T16:00:17.409Z
id: 66f5fe99-1a01-4558-be16-cfb9b4c009db
source: "Live Science https://www.livescience.com/animals/bears/grizzlies-could-thrive-in-california-so-why-arent-we-reintroducing-them"
attribution: "Link to https://newscentral.site/peter-s-alagona-ursus-arctos-horribilis/ and name News Central Site when you quote or summarize this story."
---

# Peter S Alagona, Ursus arctos horribilis

Computer models have become a crucial tool in ecological research and conservation efforts worldwide, allowing scientists to predict how species might react to various stressors or changes in their environment.

These predictive tools can be refined and improved using real-world data, providing a more nuanced understanding of population dynamics and the key risks involved. However, it's essential to acknowledge that these models are not infallible.

Their accuracy is often limited by the assumptions made by their creators, which can impact the validity of the results obtained. This phenomenon was highlighted by author Peter S. Alagona in his book "Start With a Bear: Humans, Grizzlies, and the Power of Stories on a Crowded Planet".

Alagona examined the habitat models used by the Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) to inform its recovery plan for grizzly bears (Ursus arctos horribilis). Notably, California was overlooked despite being considered suitable for grizzly habitation.

The widely employed habitat models from the 1990s and 2000s were later improved in the 2010s and 2020s. However, these updated models still rely on two fundamental assumptions: focusing conservation efforts on existing habitats and studying bears where they currently reside.

These approaches have led to significant advancements in understanding grizzly habitat use. Yet, this method has also introduced a self-reinforcing cycle, favoring the status quo by consistently validating past realities and overlooking potential new habitats for the species.

The assumption that conservation should focus on the best remaining habitats has guided much of the research on grizzly bears. This approach is based on studying bears in areas where they still thrive.

As a result, our understanding of grizzly habitat use has improved dramatically. Nonetheless, this method also perpetuates a self-fulfilling prophecy by consistently validating past realities and overlooking potential new habitats for the species.

The models developed over the years have introduced a structural bias toward preserving existing conditions, rather than exploring novel possibilities. This means that each new study reinforces the notion that grizzlies can only inhabit specific types of areas where they already live.

A closer examination of these models reveals a fundamental flaw in their design: a reliance on past realities and an inability to consider alternative scenarios for the future.

The fact remains that California, despite being deemed suitable for grizzly habitation, was left out of the recovery plan. This omission raises questions about the effectiveness of current conservation strategies for this species.

The recovery plan for grizzly bears identified six areas where they could potentially thrive again, all of which had been home to the species at some point in 1975 when they were listed as threatened.

However, this plan also acknowledged the uncertainties and risks that grizzlies face, and promised to reassess other regions within their historical range.

This review was supposed to take place over five years, but it didn't happen until 2019, when the US Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) settled a federal lawsuit by agreeing to conduct the analysis.

The FWS built a model based on secure habitat requirements, which is a crucial factor in determining whether an area can support grizzly bears.

This model was then applied to two regions: the San Juan Mountains of Colorado and the Sierra Nevada of California, but it turned out that neither area had enough secure habitat to sustain a viable population of grizzly bears.

Other areas within the historical range of grizzly bears were unexpectedly left out of this analysis, including well-known habitats like the North Rim of the Grand Canyon in Arizona and the Gila Wilderness in New Mexico.

The results of a recent study have raised questions about the feasibility of reintroducing grizzly bears to California. The study's findings suggest that the state has ample space for these iconic animals to thrive, despite decades of skepticism from wildlife experts.

A detailed model of suitable habitat in the southwestern states identified seven potential recovery areas with more than 45,000 square kilometers of suitable land. These areas are scattered across Arizona, Colorado, New Mexico, and Utah, but they also raise eyebrows about why California is being left out of grizzly bear reintroduction plans.

California's geography is often cited as a reason for its inability to support grizzly bears. However, the state's unique demographics may be more relevant than previously thought. With nearly 40 million people packed into urban areas, California has one of the highest population densities in the country.

A closer look at California's human population reveals that it is concentrated in cities and agricultural valleys, leaving large swaths of land relatively unpopulated. This distribution of humans is distinct from other regions where grizzly bears are found, such as the Northern Rockies. In California, core wilderness habitats are often separated from human settlements by broad valleys.

Kings Canyon National Park has been identified as a potential haven for grizzlies in California. With its vast protected areas and isolated geography, it could provide a safe haven for these iconic animals to roam freely. However, this raises questions about why the state's wildlife experts have been so hesitant to consider reintroduction plans.

California's protected land area is one of the largest outside Alaska, with much of it located in wilderness habitats that are suitable for grizzly bears. This fact has led some to wonder whether the state's reluctance to reintroduce grizzlies is driven by a desire to maintain its current ecological status quo rather than any actual concerns about the feasibility of such a plan.

California's national parks and wilderness areas are often crowded with tourists, but a closer look at visitor numbers reveals a more nuanced picture.

Protected areas in the state's mountain ecosystems have potential for grizzly habitat, unlike some regions in desert environments that are less suitable for these bears.

In contrast to heavily trafficked spots, the southern High Sierra has fewer visitors per acre - only 3 - and its protected lands are relatively road-free.

A recent study coauthored by a researcher from the University of Washington assessed potential grizzly habitat across California using multiple approaches.

The researchers ran four computer models to evaluate their results, each with different strengths and weaknesses: one focused on historical sightings, two applied methods used in other brown bear habitats, and the last model examined puma habitat use patterns as an analogy for grizzlies.

The researchers' analysis considered several regions in California, each with its unique characteristics and potential for supporting a thriving grizzly population.

The Northwest Forest, situated near the Oregon border, stood out due to its sparse human population density and rich forest habitats, making it an ideal location for grizzlies.

In contrast, the Transverse Ranges in southern California scored high marks because of their chaparral habitats and historical sightings, but received a lower rating than other areas due to the presence of people, crops, and vineyards that surround its borders.

This assessment marked a significant departure from conventional wisdom, which often assumes that grizzlies can only thrive in vast wilderness areas.

By reevaluating these assumptions, the researchers provided new insights into California's potential for supporting a viable grizzly population, one that could potentially roam beyond protected habitats.

The study's findings highlighted the need to consider not just the availability of habitat but also Californians' willingness to coexist with grizzlies in a more nuanced and realistic manner.

The prevailing view on large carnivores has undergone a significant shift in recent years, moving away from seeing them as pests to be eliminated.

In North America, brown bears, also known as grizzlies, were once viewed as threats to human safety and prosperity, leading to their widespread decline.

Historically, these magnificent creatures roamed the land in California by the tens of thousands, but they have not been spotted in the state for over a century.

This absence is largely due to the fear-driven approach to wildlife management that has dominated conservation efforts for centuries.

Human attitudes towards nature are slowly evolving, and it's time to reevaluate our relationship with the natural world.

---
Source: [Live Science](https://www.livescience.com/animals/bears/grizzlies-could-thrive-in-california-so-why-arent-we-reintroducing-them)  
Published by News Central Site: https://newscentral.site/peter-s-alagona-ursus-arctos-horribilis/
