(Version française disponible ici)
The climate disaster is wreaking havoc on our planet. Over thirty years in the past, 1000’s of scientists from across the globe issued a warning: humanity and the pure world have been on a collision course. That warning has turn into our lived reality. Humanity will not be merely colliding with nature; we’re driving the collapse by means of a mannequin of financial and authorized globalization that treats the Earth as limitless.
Every yr, we launch extra greenhouse gases into the ambiance, temperatures rise to unprecedented levels, and forests burn in each nook of the globe. Nineteen to 23 million tons of plastic enter our oceans yearly, together with 300 to 400 million tons of heavy metals, solvents, and poisonous sludge. One million species are at present threatened with extinction. Multiple ecological tipping points could quickly be crossed, with profound and irreversible penalties.
Despite the magnitude of the disaster, the efforts of the worldwide neighborhood stay inadequate. One of the important thing points is that negotiations take time. In 2016, for example, the Paris Agreement lastly got here into drive, setting a worldwide goal to maintain the rise in temperature under two levels Celsius. That instrument, nevertheless, solely got here to fruition after years of painful negotiation. More not too long ago, the High Seas Treaty was adopted to guard biodiversity within the excessive seas, however solely after a number of years of negotiations. If historical past is any information, any new treaties we have to handle excellent environmental points will equally take years to barter.
Some extent of no return
We merely should not have that point. Humanity has reached some extent of no return and can now not afford such prolonged negotiations. The decade by which we discover ourselves will be decisive, however we lack the instruments to reply shortly to the existential challenges we face.
Today’s dominant authorized and financial doctrines, solid throughout the Holocene to drive industrial growth and international commerce, weren’t conceived with the complicated dynamics of the Anthropocene in thoughts. They have been constructed for stability and progress in an period of presumed abundance, and as such, typically lack the responsiveness wanted to interact with ecological thresholds, suggestions loops, and planetary boundaries.
New situations name for brand new options. It is time to rethink the best way we resolve environmental disputes and negotiate agreements extra effectively. To achieve this, we’d like new mechanisms that may actually foster collaboration and cooperation on the worldwide stage. This is the place environmental mediation is available in.
Mediation: an underutilized instrument
Mediation is a staple of many justice techniques worldwide. At its core, it includes negotiations between events to resolve a dispute or attain an settlement, however with the help of a impartial, neutral, and impartial third get together. Mediators who play this position are educated to establish the pursuits that lie behind the events’ positions and to unpack their disagreements in a approach that’s typically extra environment friendly than direct negotiation.
The abilities – and typically even the artwork – that these mediators convey to the desk have the potential to reshape the negotiation of environmental disputes and treaties. That concept will not be completely new. Mediation is already used to resolve environmental conflicts in varied home contexts. In a 2015 guide, the United Nations Environment Program (UNEP) illustrated how mediation helped clear up complicated environmental disputes on totally different continents.
In Canada, mediation helped resolve a battle among the many forestry business, environmental teams and First Nations over logging in British Columbia’s Great Bear Rainforest. Through dialogue, the events reached an unprecedented settlement that protects 85 per cent of the forest whereas offering a framework for sustainable logging.
Yet, regardless of its successes, the facility of mediation stays largely untapped on the worldwide stage. While that context differs from home ones, each politically and within the authorized devices that will apply, mediation holds the identical potential. As the UNEP itself noted greater than ten years in the past, “Mediation has been underutilized by the international system in addressing disputes over natural resources … the international system still lags behind in identifying or acting on opportunities for proactive use of mediation as a tool.”
It is now time to bridge that hole and contain skilled mediators in environmental talks to facilitate a course of that has turn into too cumbersome to cope with the complicated and dynamic points we at present face.
Speed up the method by means of mediation
What would that imply, concretely? Imagine that two neighbouring international locations search to attenuate air and water air pollution crossing their borders. Under a extra conventional framework, their representatives would have interaction in direct negotiations, which could shortly turn into protracted as every get together turns into entrenched of their respective positions.
Past expertise exhibits that involving a mediator may speed up the method by means of 4 totally different phases. First, a preliminary part would contain the events concluding a mediation protocol by means of which they would choose their mediator, venue and timetable, establish their representatives, and agree on the mediator’s mandate.
With that protocol in place, the second, preparatory part, would contain the events and the mediator collectively laying the foundations for the mediation by figuring out its scope, work plan, and logistics. At that stage, the mediator might also develop a preliminary evaluation of the choices out there.
In most instances, the mediator will meet individually with every get together to know their positions and, typically, establish the underlying pursuits and motivations that could be hidden behind them. These conferences could present a possibility to check potential options to be developed additional throughout the mediation.
The third part is the mediation itself. In environmental issues, scientists and specialists are sometimes referred to as upon to current technical studies that make clear areas of disagreement, permitting all stakeholders to work with a typical set of data. The negotiation itself can then proceed, guided by the mediator’s skilled hand, to resolve every challenge and attain an settlement between the events. Even if no settlement is reached, mediation typically permits the events to circumscribe their disagreement and boil it all the way down to a minimal set of key factors. Finally, the fourth stage includes implementing the settlement reached between the events.
Create a specialised unit
How can that system take form? Throughout the world, skilled mediators can be found and able to contribute their distinctive talent set to addressing the climate disaster. We suggest the creation of a brand new International Climate Mediation Unit, which may very well be positioned throughout the UNEP or the UN Secretariat, thereby uniting these specialists below a single workforce.
This specialised unit would come with subject mediators able to resolve conflicts generated by the climate disaster and its penalties, together with the increasingly frequent displacement of populations within the wake of disasters.
It would additionally embrace governance mediators ready to assist international locations attain climate agreements. And it will embrace tax mediators working towards the institution of a world tax system that generates the monetary means required to forestall and compensate for environmental hurt.
This proposal is an pressing different that isn’t merely a procedural repair, however a name to revamp how we resolve battle in a world on hearth. This name for a brand new structure of environmental mediation confronts the institutional paralysis that has lengthy stalled motion on what’s broadly understood at this time as an existential menace to humanity and all of life.
The solely lacking piece is the political willingness to shepherd and implement this method. Canada can play a key position in that endeavour. We take delight in our place on the worldwide stage and, particularly, within the position we now have performed in fostering peace and settlement.
Our authorities can act now and lead the event of this new answer for addressing the climate disaster. Only then can we start to weave a shared future, what the Anishinaabe name mamidosewin: strolling collectively towards a typical vacation spot.
This <a goal=”_blank” href=”https://policyoptions.irpp.org/2025/09/mediation-environnementale/”>article</a> first appeared on <a goal=”_blank” href=”https://policyoptions.irpp.org”>Policy Options</a> and is republished right here below a Creative Commons license.<img src=”https://policyoptions.irpp.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/po_favicon-150×150.png” type=”width:1em;height:1em;margin-left:10px;”><img id=”republication-tracker-tool-source” src=”https://policyoptions.irpp.org/?republication-pixel=true&post=301055″ type=”width:1px;height:1px;”>