'Exterminate All the Brutes' review: Raoul Peck's HBO docuseries hybrid offers a searing second take on US history


Weaving his personal biography and private experiences into the story, the Haitian filmmaker has produced a hard-to-describe challenge, mixing detailed dramatic sequences, animation and documentary parts, with actor Josh Hartnett, considerably distractingly, representing the face of oppression and genocide via numerous phases of history.

The central theme, nonetheless, focuses on a lengthy highway of racism constructed on the tentpoles of “Civilization. Colonization. Extermination.” Peck attracts on creator Joseph Conrad’s “Heart of Darkness” for the title, earlier than continuing to dissect the manner history is written and spun by the survivors.

As Peck notes, the “discoverers” of America and others via the centuries characterised themselves as such, utilizing that as cowl to grab the lands of Indigenous peoples, leaving a path of damaged treaties and abuse.

“Only through killing, and displacement, does it become uninhabited,” Peck, who supplies the gravelly-voiced narration all through, observes, drawing a line from the previous via the white-supremacist actions of right this moment. Former President Trump is proven referring to undocumented immigrants as “animals” (remarks he later sought to clarify) — a continuation, Peck argues, of the mentality that sure individuals are someway lower than human.

Peck has sought to pressure viewers not merely to confront history, however to attach it on to the current. He additionally desires to encourage a reconsideration of the manner these occasions have been mentioned and portrayed, maybe most successfully via the incorporation of previous film clips stuffed with photographs of informal racism and stereotypes.

There’s an unavoidable sense that one thing as overtly provocative as “Exterminate All the Brutes” will wind up strictly preaching to the choir. “History is a fruit of power,” Peck says early on, continuing to deconstruct some rigorously manicured storylines that kids had been informed as a technique of tearing down statues to them, figuratively if not actually.

Known for the James Baldwin-inspired documentary “I Am Not Your Negro” and “Sometimes in April,” an HBO drama about the Rwandan genocide, Peck blends these two types, breaking his sections down with subtitles like “The Disturbing Confidence of Ignorance.” The narrative derives inspiration from a number of scholarly works, together with Roxanne Dunbar-Ortiz’s “An Indigenous Peoples’ History of the United States.”

In the press supplies, HBO notes that Peck “freely weaves together scripted and unscripted content,” which may make “Exterminate All the Brutes” really feel messy, and in locations even disorienting. That would possibly clarify the community’s choice to consolidate the 4 hours over successive nights.

The web impact, nonetheless, succeeds at the very least in spurring contemplation not solely relating to what we find out about history, however how — and who — conveyed that to us. While Peck’s unorthodox method won’t win many converts, the challenge’s existence is, if not fairly a miracle, its personal sort of victory.

“Exterminate All the Brutes” will air April 7-8 at 9 p.m. ET on HBO, which, like, NCS, is a unit of WarnerMedia.



With information from

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *