Latest
Wednesday, November 18, 2026
  • New YorkNY
  • LondonLDN
  • TokyoTYO
Business

Alpha School Faces Disappointing AI Tool Usage

Despite offering an exceptional AI-powered tool, students are not using it as intended at Alpha School.

We built the AI study tool every parent wants. Almost nobody used it
Source: Fortune

A pioneering education project has hit a significant snag after investing heavily in artificial intelligence to support student learning.

Alpha School, a cutting-edge educational platform that's been gaining national attention, is now facing a stark reality: despite offering an exceptional AI-powered tool, students are not using it as intended.

The AI study aid was designed to fill the gap between human tutoring sessions, providing personalized math practice and real-time feedback. With over 10,000 exercises and a patient AI assistant on hand, students could have benefited from seamless support at any time.

But the numbers tell a different story: only about one in ten students opted for this advanced learning tool. Moreover, many who did start using it soon lost interest and dropped out altogether.

The disappointing usage rate raises important questions about how education technology is being implemented in schools, particularly as Alpha School expands into public institutions in Texas and South Carolina, where districts are considering a significant shift towards AI-driven instruction.

Students who used Khan Academy's AI tutor in Tennessee middle schools showed limited engagement, with most messages consisting of brief answers or clicks on suggested prompts. Despite nearly every student trying the tool, the median student interacted with it in less than a third of practice days and only 17% of sessions where mistakes were made. These findings mirror Khan Academy's own reports that approximately 15% of students with access to the AI tutor actually use it.

However, when human tutors took charge of managing students' learning, a significant shift occurred. In this setup, each student's tutor selected practice exercises tailored to their needs, assigned tasks, and followed up at subsequent lessons. This new approach led to increased completion rates for assignments, with more than half of students fulfilling their commitments compared to about 10% who used the app independently.

The change was remarkable because it involved the same app and exercises as before. The only difference was the introduction of a human element, a tutor familiar with each student's progress and expectations. This hybrid model is now being replicated in Tutorela, an education platform built on the understanding that human interaction can significantly boost engagement and learning outcomes.

Tutorela's designers were motivated by this discovery to create a system that combines AI support with personalized guidance from educators. By placing humans at the forefront of student learning, they aim to make a more substantial impact than relying solely on technology.

The success of this approach underscores the importance of balancing technological innovation with human interaction in education. As platforms like Tutorela expand into new markets and institutions, it remains to be seen whether their hybrid model can replicate these results at scale.

The limitations of AI-driven education tools have become apparent in our own experiments. Despite providing high-quality content and instant feedback, student participation remained low. It appears that personalized learning materials alone are insufficient to motivate students.

In our experience, the quality of educational content is not the primary issue. Students today have access to a vast array of free, high-quality explanations online. However, this wealth of information does not automatically translate into improved academic performance.

The absence of human interaction and accountability seems to be the critical factor in determining student engagement. A child may complete worksheets generated by AI, but without someone to hold them accountable for their work, they are less likely to put in effort. This dynamic was evident in our own research.

AI can certainly augment the tutoring process by providing additional support between lessons. It can offer explanations and practice materials that human tutors cannot match. However, this is only effective when a tutor sets the direction and goals for the student's learning.

The problem arises when AI assumes a more prominent role, replacing human interaction altogether. In such cases, students may feel less motivated to engage with the material, as there is no one to hold them accountable for their progress.

Ultimately, school leaders must consider how they will ensure that students use these tools effectively. Simply relying on the software itself may not be enough, as our research and others have shown.

To make AI tools effective for parents, it's crucial to pair them with human support.

This approach is a far cry from relying solely on automated learning systems. A teacher or tutor can set clear goals and provide regular check-ins, helping students stay on track and addressing any issues that may arise. By combining the strengths of both humans and AI, education can become more personalized and engaging.

The future of learning will not replace human instructors with machines but rather augment their role with technology.

To succeed in today's rapidly changing landscape, companies must be agile and adaptable. They need to stay attuned to shifting consumer needs and technological advancements. This means building organizations that can pivot quickly in response to new opportunities and challenges.

Effective leaders recognize the importance of adaptability and build their teams accordingly. By fostering a culture of continuous learning and innovation, they empower their organizations to thrive in an ever-evolving world.

Facts based on reporting originally published by Fortune.

You may republish this story, in full or in part, if you credit News Central Site and link to it (licence CC BY 4.0). Photos are not included.